Emerging Role of Visual Biofeedback in Rehabilitation Following ACL Reconstruction
Article information
Abstract
Following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR), neuromuscular deficits such as impaired proprioception, altered muscle activation timing, and inter-limb loading asymmetries commonly persist and may increase the risk of ACL reinjury. Visual biofeedback has been widely used to remediate these deficits by providing task-relevant information to reduce high-risk kinematic and kinetic deviations. This narrative review synthesizes clinical applications of visual biofeedback following ACLR across three domains: (1) balance and postural control, (2) quadriceps strength and inter-limb loading symmetry, (3) landing/cutting mechanics related to reinjury risk. Evidence indicates that visual biofeedback improves postural stability and joint position sense, and it can enhance engagement with balance tasks. During weight-bearing exercise, real-time displays of vertical ground reaction force (vGRF) or center of pressure (COP) reduce loading asymmetry and may facilitate quadriceps recruitment in the surgical limb. Visual biofeedback also reduces knee abduction moment and valgus angle, and improves vGRF symmetry during landing or cutting. However, squat-based visual biofeedback does not improve peak knee extension moment symmetry during landing, indicating limited transfer of squat-based visual biofeedback to landing mechanics. These findings show that visual biofeedback can help improve deficits associated with post-ACLR when the feedback variable and training task are aligned with the intended clinical outcome. Future work, including task-specific visual biofeedback protocols that incorporate jump landing and cutting, appears necessary to facilitate correction of inter-limb loading asymmetry during high-demand tasks following ACLR.
Introduction
Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury is one of the most consequential musculoskeletal injuries in sport, frequently resulting in long-term functional deficits, increased risk of reinjury, substantial time lost from participation, and early onset of osteoarthritis[1-5]. ACL reconstruction (ACLR) has been known to be a standard surgical treatment for restoring mechanical stability of the knee. However, the success of the procedure is profoundly dependent on the quality of postoperative rehabilitation. Despite structured rehabilitation programs, reinjury rates remain substantial. Current evidence indicates that approximately 20-30% of young, physically active athletes experience either ipsilateral graft failure or contralateral anterior cruciate ligament injury within two years of return to sport[6-9].
A major challenge following ACLR is the restoration of neuromuscular control, which involves the coordinated activation of muscles in response to sensory input to produce stable and efficient movement. Although muscle strength and range of motion may appear fully restored, neuromuscular deficits such as diminished proprioception, altered muscle activation, and asymmetric loading patterns often persist for months or even years after surgery[10-13]. These deficits can compromise movement efficiency, elevate joint loading, and contribute to the increased risk of reinjury.
To address these deficits, visual biofeedback has been widely used to provide task-relevant information that facilitates the modification of aberrant movement patterns following ACLR[14-17]. It is considered an effective approach because it directly engages sensory motor system, facilitates the identification and correction of altered joint mechanics, and promotes motor learning. Therefore, the purpose of this review is to provide a comprehensive overview of its clinical applications following ACLR, summarize emerging research trends, and outline future directions necessary for the development of evidence-based rehabilitation strategies.
Clinical Application of Visual Biofeedback Following ACLR
Balance and Postural Control
Visual biofeedback has been shown to improve postural stability in individuals after ACL reconstruction. Molka et al. [18] reported that a four-week rehabilitation program using visual biofeedback significantly reduced center of pressure (COP) sway velocity in the sagittal plane under both eyes-open and eyes-closed conditions. The participants also completed a dynamic balance test approximately eight seconds faster compared to their baseline performance and outperformed healthy controls on this task. Previous research reported that using visual biofeedback during balance training yielded better outcomes in both balance and proprioception[19]. In that study, both the visual biofeedback group and no-feedback controls improved their Berg Balance Scale scores, but only the visual feedback group demonstrated better joint position sense at 45 and 90 degrees of knee flexion. These findings indicate that visual biofeedback effectively improves postural control and proprioception when integrated with balance training.
Recently, interactive virtual reality (VR) systems have been used to engage patients in balance tasks with real-time visual biofeedback. A systematic review reported that VR-based therapy (VRBT) significantly improves knee function, strength, range of motion (ROM), and dynamic balance, and more effectively reduces pain than conventional rehabilitation approaches following ACL injury[16]. Consistent with these findings, another systematic review concluded that combining proprioceptive training with VR-based exercises is effective in improving balance in athletes after ACLR[20]. The interactive, game-like aspects of VR may help engage athletes in balance tasks, which may improve postural control and balance following ACL injury. Based on these findings, incorporating visual biofeedback with proprioceptive or balance training could accelerate improvement in balance and postural control in individuals undergoing rehabilitation after ACLR.
Quadriceps Strength and Inter-Limb Loading Symmetry
Restoring quadriceps strength and symmetrical inter-limb loading is considered a primary objective in the rehabilitation process following ACLR. Nevertheless, individuals with ACLR demonstrate persistent deficits in quadriceps strength on the surgical limb and display compensatory movement patterns that offload the surgical limb during weight-bearing activities[4]. To address these deficits, visual biofeedback has been widely used and shown to be effective in achieving these goals. Visual biofeedback commonly utilizes information on limb loading, ground reaction forces, or COP to address inter-limb loading asymmetries following ACLR. This approach allows patients with ACLR to actively engage the surgical limb during weight-bearing activities.
One common method is to provide real-time vertical ground reaction force during weight bearing activity such as squats[21-23]. In this approach, individuals stand with each foot placed on a separate force plate and monitor a visual display often presented as bar graphs or circles that represent the magnitude of vertical ground reaction forces. Real-time visual representation of ground reaction forces allows individuals with ACLR recognize inter-limb loading asymmetries and make immediate adjustments to weight distribution. This type of visual biofeedback has been shown to effectively reduce inter-limb loading asymmetries during rehabilitation[15,17,21,23]. A recent study reported that inter-limb loading symmetry in individuals with ACLR improved significantly from 0.85 to 1 when real-time visual biofeedback was provided[15]. A symmetry value of 1 indicates identical loading distribution between the two limbs.
Visual biofeedback may also facilitate quadriceps recruitment and promote strength recovery by ensuring the surgical limb is adequately loaded during rehabilitation exercises. Traditional rehabilitation approaches do not always resolve quadriceps avoidance patterns on the surgical limb following ACLR. However, when patients are guided to maintain symmetrical loading through visual biofeedback, the increased demand placed on quadriceps in the surgical limb may promote greater activation and strength development. A recent meta-analysis reported that individuals with ACL injury demonstrated greater improvements when rehabilitation incorporated virtual reality (VR) based feedback, which is a form of visual biofeedback delivered through immersive, game-like environments, compared to standard therapy[16]. Participants trained with VR-based feedback also achieved greater knee flexion range of motion and higher functional scores. These improvements may be attributed to the interactive and engaging nature of the virtual environments. In summary, visual biofeedback offers a practical approach, as it provides individuals with ACLR continuous information about weight distribution and guides them toward symmetrical loading of the surgical limb.
Correction of Landing/Cutting Mechanics and Reduction of Reinjury Risk
Targeted re-education of jump and landing mechanics is a key component of post ACLR rehabilitation because these interventions directly target aberrant frontal and sagittal plane knee loading associated with ACL injury. In particular, dynamic knee valgus, asymmetrical landing strategies, and insufficient knee flexion (i.e., stiff landings) are well-established risk factors for ACL injury[24]. These high-risk movement patterns commonly persist after ACLR without specific neuromuscular retraining. Accordingly, visual biofeedback is frequently integrated into the rehabilitation process and has demonstrated efficacy in promoting safer landing patterns during functional tasks[1,25]. For example, individuals following ACLR may perform drop jumps or hop drills while receiving visual biofeedback on frontal plane knee alignment or force distribution. This feedback can be as simple as a laser or marker indicating knee position relative to the foot, or as sophisticated as force plate data showing impact forces on each leg. A previous study demonstrated that incorporating visual biofeedback during drop vertical jumps resulted in a 32.8% reduction in knee abduction moment[1]. Another recent study reported that visual biofeedback decreased peak knee abduction moment by 17.1% and reduced knee valgus angle by 1.5 degrees during side-step cutting[26]. A separate study provided combined visual and tactile biofeedback during squats and subsequently examined whether these training effects transferred to landing mechanics during stop-jumps[17]. Results from this study indicated that squat-based visual biofeedback improved vertical ground reaction force symmetry during the landing phase of stop-jumps. However, peak knee extension moment symmetry, a risk factor for ACL injury, did not improve, indicating limited transfer of squat-based visual biofeedback to landing mechanics. Incorporating task-specific visual biofeedback that provides information on landing mechanics appears to be necessary to reduce landing-related risk factors and, in turn, reduce ACL injury risk.
Conclusions
Neuromuscular deficits including altered muscle activation, diminished proprioception, and inter-limb loading asymmetries commonly persist following ACLR. Visual biofeedback has been widely employed and has demonstrated efficacy in addressing these deficits. Research shows that visual biofeedback effectively improves balance and postural control, quadriceps strength and engagement, inter-limb loading symmetry, and landing mechanics. Task-specific visual biofeedback appears to be necessary, given that squat-based visual biofeedback does not improve landing mechanics, particularly peak knee extension moment symmetry. Future studies should focus on task-specific visual biofeedback protocols for high-demand activities (e.g., jump landing and cutting) to promote safer landing strategies and reduce inter-limb loading asymmetries following ACLR.
Notes
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by Incheon National University Research Grant in 2024 (2024-0296).
The author declares no conflict of interest.